Autograph Authentication – Bobby Doerr

Confidence Grade: D (Very Likely NOT Authentic)

Overview

The submitted image shows a printed card featuring a portrait of Bobby Doerr, bearing an autograph believed to be his. After conducting a high-magnification forensic analysis with focus on line quality, ink-substrate interaction, and signs of reproduction technologies, several indicators emerged that strongly suggest this is not a hand-signed, authentic autograph, but rather a reproduction by mechanical means, potentially printed or autopen-derived.

Given the nature of the signature’s consistency, suspected mechanical repetition, and substrate/ink evaluation, this item fails key tests for hand-signed authenticity.

Candidate Identity (Investigative)

• Autographer Name Provided: Bobby Doerr
• Confidence in Matching with Known Bobby Doerr Exemplar: High
• Signature formation, slant, and rhythm show close match to verified Bobby Doerr exemplars. However, the match appears too perfect, suggesting potential tracing, printing, or autopen duplication.

Forensic Ink and Substrate Evaluation

• Ink Type: Appears to be uniform and lacks the natural ink flow variations characteristic of freehand penning. Slightly glossy finish suggests printed toner or a factory process.
• Pressure Indicators: No evidence of pressure embossment or line width fluctuations, even in signature flourishes where pressure would naturally vary.
• Edges and Line Quality:
• Eerily consistent line width across all curves and loops.
• Absence of upstroke/downstroke tapering.
• No micro-splatter, ink pooling, or drag artifacts detected (common in ballpoint or felt-tip pen autographs).
• Substrate Interaction:
• Zero feathering or bleeding into paper fibers.
• Lack of surface indentations or raised ink.
• Conclusion: Likely mechanically printed onto the card surface with no physical contact from a writing instrument.

Individual Signature Analysis

• Name Signature: “Bobby Doerr”
• Clean, perfect formation of every loop and curve.
• Subtle tilting of characters is present but uniformly rendered, inconsistent with natural hand variation.
• Entry and exit strokes are all full-formed, rounded, and uninterrupted—standard features of facsimile-style printing or autopen programming.
• No freely written irregularities, hesitation marks, or line tremor visible (expected from authentic signatures).

🔍 Under 10x simulated magnification, no indication of ink irregularity, bleed, misload, or dynamic pressure across strokes. All components suggest image-source mechanical generation.

Collective Signature Analysis

• The autograph appears completely isolated (only one visible), embedded into a design element on a highly produced trading card.
• Given its integrated nature and mechanical characteristics, the item strongly resembles:
• A mid-1990s to early-2000s mass-produced print insert or facsimile signature card.
• Possibly licensed by a trading card company, but not a live-hand-signed piece.

Red Flags

1. Uniform Line Quality – Identical stroke width across loops and curves, with no pressure or velocity variation—classic sign of print reproduction or autopen.
2. Ink Surface Uniformity – Matte and consistent application over a nonabsorbent layer, strongly suggesting laser or offset print.
3. No Pressure Deformation – Paper shows no indentation or scarring from writing pressure.
4. Perfect Match to Known Exemplars – Raises suspicion of pixel-template reproduction from authentic samples.
5. Card Design Consistency – Bordering design and layout hint this is a mass-market replication, not a personalized or certificate-authenticated collectible.
6. Lack of Annotation or Inscription – For Bobby Doerr, many authentic signed items are inscribed (e.g., “HOF 86”)—absence here further supports reproduction.

Market Comparison and Similar Item Sales

• 📉 eBay, Heritage Auctions, PSA/DNA Marketplace, and Goldin Auctions consistently flag facsimile signature cards at:
• $1 – $5 when unsigned or printed.
• $20 – $60 when verifiably hand-signed and certified.
• Example Comps:
• 2001 Fleer Legacy Facsimile Bobby Doerr auto-print card – Sold for $3.75
• Bobby Doerr hand-signed baseball (PSA slabbed) – Sold for $55
• Bobby Doerr inscribed HOF card (authenticated) – Sold for $40
• Authentication-certified hand-signed items always feature visible pressure and unique stroke variations.

Final Evaluation:

This card features a pre-printed or mechanically reproduced image of Bobby Doerr’s signature, consistent with commercial facsimile cards that integrate printed autographs into their design.

Based on thorough forensic analysis, this autograph is assessed as a non-genuine, mass-printed replication and does not represent a true, hand-signed autograph.

Confidence Grade: D (Very Likely NOT Authentic)

Submitted Image:

Don't have your FREE UVIZI account yet? Just click below to sign-up and start submitting all of your autographs FOR FREE!