Verification for Tiger Woods | Item # 1473
Autograph Authentication – Tiger Woods
Confidence Grade: C (Likely NOT Authentic)
Overview
The presented item is a color photograph of a professional golfer mid-swing, identified through visual context as Tiger Woods. Over the photograph is a large silver-colored signature, presumably in paint pen. The image includes contextual notes referencing “Lee R.,” though no additional provenance or certification is provided. The signature is being assessed for forensic authenticity.
Tiger Woods is classified as a High-Risk Autographer, necessitating stringent scrutiny. His signature has been heavily forged in the collectibles market due to its high demand and relatively uniform presentation style.
Candidate Identity (Investigative)
- Confirmed Identity Match: Tiger Woods
- Confidence: High
- Rationale: The visual context clearly depicts Tiger Woods. The signature form visually approximates known styles used by Woods in autographs from professional signing sessions during the 2000s–2010s, including the characteristic “T” loop and sharp angular transitional strokes. This match is qualified by internal exemplars. Nonetheless, signature form alone cannot confirm authenticity.
Forensic Ink and Substrate Evaluation
- Ink Type: Appears to be silver metallic or paint pen, consistent with common signing tools for glossy photographic prints.
- Pressure Variation: Shows inconsistent depth and opacity, especially in entry/exit strokes. Suggests non-mechanical application; however, some areas show suspicious flattening.
- Edge Integrity: Upon 10x simulated magnification, the stroke edges exhibit some mild feathering, but overall appear flattened and slightly glossy—which may point to transfer, print, or autopen over glossy substrate.
- Ink Reflection: The ink’s reflective behavior under light appears uniform throughout, a trait found in both live signatures and certain types of mechanical reproduction (e.g., foil-enhanced print overlays).
- Ink/Substrate Behavior: Minor signs of surface-level adhesion (not absorbed into substrate)—consistent with paint pen—but with certain trails that suggest possibly non-handled implementation.
Individual Signature Analysis
-
Letterform Consistency:
-
The large flourished “T” aligns with Tiger Woods’ known autographs.
-
The central arc and descender bear similarity to typical exemplars from authenticated items.
-
However, too-clean formations on key downstrokes (especially leading into what may be a stylized “W”) diverge from known pressure inconsistencies in live-signed items.
-
Entry/Exit Strokes:
-
Abrupt entry on upper-left “T” stroke lacks natural tapering.
-
Exit stroke smoothness suggests potential digital rendering or autopen smoothing during motion jams.
-
Line Quality and Flow:
-
Several vertical lines show signs of mechanical consistency with no expected micro-tremors or human-induced hesitations.
-
Lacks random micro-variation normally seen under 10x magnification in authentic, unassisted live autographs.
-
Velocity & Rhythm Analysis:
-
Stroke velocity appears unnaturally constant in long curves.
-
No visible pen lifts or pressure distortions in mid-sections—signs typical of autopen or high-end reproduction.
Collective Signature Analysis
-
Integration with Image:
-
Signature blends seamlessly with the glossy surface but lacks physical pigment disruption expected in fully hand-applied paint pen signatures on glossy prints.
-
Contrasting density shifts are absent, limiting any evidence of human tool hesitation.
-
Contextual Size and Placement:
-
Signature is oversized and centrally placed over the subject’s legs, often seen in mass-produced images meant for resale.
-
Placement is common in bulk-signed memorabilia—both authentic and imposters.
Red Flags
- Mechanical Line Consistency: Several long pennants in the signature display no variation in ink width or tapering at natural turning points, a hallmark of autopen or print forgery.
- Lack of Tapering: Notably absent from both the start and end points; visually flat, which is inconsistent with live paint pen dynamics.
- Potential Transfer or Overlay Print: Signature sits a bit too “cleanly” atop the photo’s glossy surface—possibly screen-printed or applied with a transfer sheet to simulate authentic ink.
- No Provenance or COA: No traceable certification or originating source documented. Highest-risk signatures without any provenance or forensic validation should be viewed skeptically.
- High-Risk Autographer: Tiger Woods’ signature remains one of the most frequently forged in sports memorabilia markets. This item lacks sufficient unique identifiers to overcome this category bias.
Market Comparison and Similar Item Sales
-
Recent Auction at Heritage Auctions (HA.com, Lot #64092)
-
Item: Autographed Tiger Woods photo (8×10) with PSA/DNA certification
-
Sold For: $900 USD
-
Comment: Featured clear pen lifts and ink pooling consistent with live signing. Included full provenance.
-
Goldin Auctions – November 2023 Event
-
Item: Signed Tiger Woods print (color), UDA-certified
-
Sold For: $1,250 USD
-
eBay Listings
-
Ungraded Oversize Photo, Similar Ink/Style:
- Price Range: $95 – $350 (with questionable authenticity, often unsigned)
- Note: Many pieces in these ranges show visual similarity to the above item but lack authentication; many reveal autopen or print features under magnification.
Final Conclusion
While the signature’s form bears resemblance to authentic Tiger Woods autographs, the forensic evidence suggests indicators of mechanical reproduction (especially autopen or pre-printed photographic overlay). The absence of natural pen characteristics (pressure variation, tapering, hesitation) and the high-risk context of Tiger Woods’ signature make this piece most likely a reproduction, not a live signature. Authentication cannot be confidently supported without stronger provenance or ink/substrate confirmation.
Confidence Grade: C (Likely NOT Authentic)
Submitted Image:
